She made a comment to the effect the latest trend among editors is they believe the word THAT should be eliminated from the English language. I think she still likes me even though I gave her my opinion. Trends come and go, probably at the whims of the editors from the big New York publishing houses. Several years ago, the "trend" revolved around whether to use THAT or WHICH, with THAT tending to be favored. If I don't like the trend, I'll just wait five years, and maybe it will change.
However, I did realize I really did use the word THAT an awful lot in my manuscript. Like many writers, I tend to overuse the word. I truly felt grateful she pointed it out to me. In fact, do you have any idea how many times so far while writing this blog post I typed the word THAT only to delete it and reword my sentence? More than a handful.
I am not ready to ban the word THAT from the English language or my writing. However, I have decided from now on I need to review each use of the word THAT in my manuscripts. Can I eliminate it, use another word instead, or reword the sentence completely to create a more effective sentence?
Figure 2 |
:
figure 3 |
Need to cut a couple hundred words from your manuscript? Try using CTRL+F to find all the times you use the word THAT in your manuscript.
By going through your document in this manner, you can review each time you use the word THAT to see if you want it to stay as is, or if you want to make a change. The following is a section of rough draft from my current work in progress. (Oh, all right, I admit I salted it with a few more thats than I originally wrote.) But, by seeing how I originally wrote the sentence and reviewing some possible changes, it can give a writer an idea of how she or he might improve her/his writing style.
She had lost everyone that was important to her in her life.
Since the time that
she had been little, she had heard how the War Between the States had been hard
on the Parmley family. Her father, Jacob, had fought, caught up in that bloody conflict
between Missouri and Kansas. Her older brother, Jacob Junior, called Jake, was
a product of their parents still being together before he enlisted at the start
of that war.
Evidently, Papa had come on leave long enough for her to be conceived, although
the war was over before he saw her at two years old. Then had come her little
brother. Thinking back on her father's tendency for depression, Lulu realized that because of the war, in some ways, her
father had left the family emotionally long before his life ended.
First, her mother and younger brother had died while
the family still lived back in Missouri. That had left her father with two small children
to care for along with his failing farm. Eventually, the lure of gold and
silver strikes plus the desire to leave behind everything that reminded him of the
war had tempted him to sell his farm and take his two children west.
She had lost everyone who had been important to her. Since the time she had been little, she had heard how the Ward Between the States had been hard on the Parmley family. Her father, Jacob, had fought, caught up in the bloody conflict between Missouri and Kansas. Her older brother, Jacob Junior, called Jake, had been a product of their parents still being together before their father's enlistment. Evidently, Papa had come home on leave long enough for her to be conceived, although the war had ended before he saw her at two years of age. Then had come her little brother. Thinking back on her father's tendency for depression, Lulu realized because of the war, in some ways her father had left the family emotionally long before his life ended.
first, her mother and younger brother had died while the family still lived back in Missouri. The loss had left her father with two small children to care for along with his failing farm. Eventually, the lure of gold and silver strikes plus the desire to leave behind him everything reminding him of the war had tempted him to sell his farm and take his two children west.
My editor friend would be proud of me. Not one time did I use the word THAT when I rewrote those two paragraphs. But, be kind and keep in mind it is still a rough draft. Those words may be changed even more before I get this story ready to submit for publication.
Robyn Echols writes
using the pen name, Zina Abbott. Her novel, Family
Secrets,
has been published by Fire Star Press and is now available on Amazon HERE and on Barnes & Nobel for Nook HERE.
Also available from Prairie Rose Publications:
Big Meadows Valentine, on Amazon Kindle HERE and on Nook HERE . The second novella in the Eastern Sierra Brides 1884 series, A Resurrected Heart, is available on Amazon Kindle HERE and on Nook HERE.
Also available from Prairie Rose Publications:
Big Meadows Valentine, on Amazon Kindle HERE and on Nook HERE . The second novella in the Eastern Sierra Brides 1884 series, A Resurrected Heart, is available on Amazon Kindle HERE and on Nook HERE.
Been there, done THAT. LOL I don't know why I got all up into the "that" addiction, but I riddled one of my manuscripts full of them--and THAT's the truth. Since then, I have been very alert to the THAT problem.
ReplyDeleteGood reminder, Robyn and clever way to find those little devils and rip them right out
Thanks, Sarah. Boy, was that an eye-opener for me. Believe me, I am much more conscious about using that word.
DeleteAll right, Robyn... Let's not come to blows over this. I'm a big proponent of trimming THATs wherever they may hide. Years and years and years ago, a newspaper copy editor with whom I worked slashed almost every single one of the suckers out of my copy with ruthless dedication. His advice: Re-read the sentence without the "that," and if the sentence still makes sense, chase the little [expletive deleted] out of there." I've clung to that advice ever since. Today, I give it to reporters whose copy **I** get to slash. (I worked long and hard to get my revenge. ;-) )
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that (**shudder**) no words should be banned from the language. Even the dreaded adverbs have their place.
Love your WIP excerpt, BTW. :-)
Thanks, Kathleen. Okay, I guess the trend for eliminating THAT has been around longer than I thought. Sometimes, it is hard to eliminate or find a good replacement way of saying something, but I did find that, yes, most of the time, it can be sent bye-bye.
DeleteThat is an interesting post. Sorry. At least it's one (nuts I was going to write that...what can I use instead...can't think!!! Going for it.) that would be harder to cut.
ReplyDeleteOh.
Interesting post.
I understand.....
DeleteGreat blog. I agree. Keep writing good books and the trends will just pass you by. :)
ReplyDeleteI hope so, Jae. Still, I keep trying to improve my craft as well as my plots, settings and characters. Thanks for the words of encouragement.
DeleteRobyn,
ReplyDeleteTHAT is an interesting article. I agree with you THAT word fads come and go and THAT we need to ride the wave and forge onward in our writing with words THAT make our stories read well.
bwahahaha
Another word fad THAT circles around every now and again is the poor, misunderstood, and wrongly maligned 'LY'-ending words.
Then, of course, there is the dreaded crime of ending a sentence with a preposition. (gasping with the back of my hand to my forehead)
I believe it was Winston Churchill who said, "Ending a sentence with a preposition is something up with which I will not put."
*grin*
Yes, I have trouble with the ending with prepositions. I have gotten to the point that I try to write the sentence using correct English grammar unless it is dialogue. Sorry, when people talk, they end with prepositions all the time.
DeleteAs for -ly words, although it is best to not overdo them, sometimes nothing else quite fits right.
College life is stressful and often times can lead to a sharp decline in the amount of time spent doing one's school work. For those of you that procrastinate, please read on for an in depth discussion on how to write a paper the night before it's due. See more rewording tool
ReplyDelete